Injecting Human Rights into International Humanitarian Law
Least Harmful means as a Principle Governing Armed Conflicts
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.18272/lr.v5i1.1226Keywords:
Human Rights Law, Humanitarian Law, regime interaction, least harmful means, right to life, combatantsAbstract
During times of war, the relationship between International Humanitarian Law and International Human Rights Law has always been controversial, and has generally been solved by prioritizing the rules of the former and minimizing the application of the latter"™s. In practice, this has translated into insufficient standards of protection for individuals and, more specifically, into the endorsement of an unrestrained right to kill enemy combatants. This paper suggests a novel approach to this regime interaction: the application of International Human Rights Law during wartime should serve as an interpretative tool of International Humanitarian Law rules, strengthening the safeguards offered by the latter and, thus, better respecting the rights of individuals during hostilities. Regarding the right to life, this interpretation would require to abandon the idea of a right to kill opponents and, instead, demand that least harmful means be employed during military operations, when possible. Lethal force should be allowed only in cases where military necessity justifies it, henceforth avoiding causing individuals more harm than that strictly required. The purpose of this article is not to advocate for a prohibition of killing combatants -as the nature of armed conflicts would render that rule unattainable- ; it is, however, to establish a principle capable of guiding combatants"™ behaviour towards a more humane conduct of hostilities.
Downloads
References
Additional Protocol to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949, and relating to the Protection of Victims of International Armed Conflicts 1125 UNTS 3 (API) Sandoz,Yves et al. Commentary on the Additional Protocols. ICRC, 1987. para. 4429.
Additional Protocol to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949, and relating to the Protection of Victims of International Armed Conflicts.
African Charter on Human"™s and People"™s Rights 1520 UNTS 217.
American Convention on Human Rights 1144 UNTS 123.
Arab Charter on Human Rights (adopted 15 September 1994).
ASEAN Human Rights Declaration (adopted 18 November 2012).
ASEAN Intergovernmental commission on Human Rights (2009).
Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials, GA Res. 45/121 (14 December 1990).
Ben-Naftali, Orna. "˜A Judgment in the Shadow of International Criminal Law"™, 5 J ICL (2007) 322.
Chevalier-Watts, Juliet. "Has human rights law become lex specialis for the European Court of Human Rights in right to life cases arising from internal armed conflicts?" (2010) IJHR 584.
Convention Against Torture (adopted 10 December 1984); 1465 UNTS 85 (CAT)
Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms 213 UNTS 222 (ECHR).
Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Discrimination Against Women (adopted 18 December 1979) 1249 UNTS 13 (CEDAW).
Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (adopted on 13 December 2006) 2515 UNTS 3 (CRPD).
Convention on the Rights of the Child (adopted 20 November 1989) 1577 UNTS 3 (CRC).
Court of Human Rights in right to life cases arising from internal armed conflicts?" (2010) IJHR 584.
Doswald-Beck, Louise. "The right to life in armed conflict: does international humanitarian law provide all the answers?" (2006) 88 IRRC 881.
Droege, Cordula. "Elective affinities? Human rights and humanitarian law" (2008) 90 IRRC 501.
ECtHR Jaloud v. Netherlands, App no. 47708/08 (20 November 2014).
ECtHR, Al-Skeini and others v UK, App no 55721/07 (ECtHR, 7 July 2011).
ECtHR, Bankovic and others v Belgium App 52207/99 (12 December 2001).
ECtHR, Cyprus v Turkey App no 25781/94 (EctHR, 2001).
ECtHR, Ergi v. Turkey App. 850/1057 (1998).
ECtHR, Hassan v United Kingdom App no 29750/09 (16 September 2014).
ECtHR, Isayeva v Russia App. 57950/00 (2005).
ECtHR, Loizidou v Turkey, App no 15318/89 (1996).
ECtHR, McCann and Others v UK App. 18984/91 (1995).
European Convention on Human Rights (1953).
Fleck, Dieter. Handbook of IHL. OUP, 2013.
Forsythe, David. The Humanitarians: The International Committee of the Red Cross. Cambridge University Press, 2005.
Gasser, Hans Peter. "International Humanitarian Law and Human Rights Law in Non-International Armed Conflicts: Joint Venture or Mutual Exclusion?" (2002) 45 GYIL.
General Assembly Resolution 1312 (XIII) (12 December 1958) UN Doc. A/38/49.
General Assembly Resolution 265 (15 March 2006) UN Doc A/RES/60/251.
General Assembly Resolution 2675 (XXV) (9 December 1970).
General Assembly Resolution 46/135 (19 December 1991) UN Doc. A/RES/ 46/135.
General Assembly Resolution 50/193 (22 December 1995) UN Doc. A/RES/50/193.
General Assembly Resolution 52/145 (12 December 1997) UN Doc. A/RES/52/145.
Geneva Conventions (adopted 12 August 1949) 75 UNTS (GCs).
Goodman, Ryan. "˜The Power to Kill or Capture Enemy Combatants"™ (2013) 24 EJIL 819.
Griffin, James. On Human Rights. OUP, 2009.
Hague Convention (IV) Respecting the Laws and Customs of War on Land and its annex: Regulations Concerning the Laws and Customs of War on Land (adopted 18 October 1907) 36 STAT 2277 (HR-IV).
Heintze, Hans-Joachim. "On the relationship between human rights law protection and international humanitarian law" (2004) 86 IRRC 789.
High Court of Justice Israel, The Public Committee against Torture in Israel et al v The Government of Israel et al (Targeted Killings), 46 ILM 375, (11 December 2006).
HRC General Comment No. 31 on The nature of the general legal obligation imposed on States Parties to the Covenant (26 May 2004) UN Doc. CCPR/C/21/Rev.1/Add.13.
HRC, Concluding Observations, Israel, CCPR/C/ISR/CO/3, 29/07/2010, 10.
HRC, Concluding Observations, Israel, CCPR/CO/78/ISR 21-08-2003, 15, http://www.adalah.org/uploads/oldfiles/upfiles/ConcludingObservations/HRC-Concluding%20Observations%20(2003).pdf (accessed: august 2016).
IACtHR, Coard v US, Report no 109/99 (29 September 1999).
IACtHR, Santo Domingo Massacre v Colombia No. N. 12.416 (30 November 2012).
ICJ, Legal Consequences for States of the Continued Presence of South Africa in Namibia (South West Africa) notwithstanding Security Council Resolution 276 (1970) (Advisory Opinion) [1971] ICJ Rep 16.
ICJ, Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory (Advisory Opinion) [2004] ICJ Rep 136.
ICJ. Legality of the Threat or Use of Nuclear Weapons. (Advisory Opinion), 1996. ICJ Rep 226.
ICRC, Conference of Government Experts on the Reaffirmation and Development of International Humanitarian Law Applicable in Armed Conflicts, ii (1974) CE/COM I1I/C 3; ICRC, "˜Weapons that May Cause Unnecessary Suffering or Have.
ICRC, Interpretative Guidance on the Notion of Direct Participation in Hostilities under International Humanitarian Law. ICRC, 2009.
ICTY, Prosecutor v Kupreskic Case No. IT-95-16-T-14, (January 2000).
III Geneva Convention, (1949).
ILC, Conclusions of the work of the Study Group on the Fragmentation of International Law: Difficulties arising from the Diversification and Expansion of International Law (2006) UN Doc A/61/10.
Indiscriminate Effects: Report on the Work of Experts"™ (1973) cited in Goodman, Ryan. "˜The Power to Kill or Capture Enemy Combatants"™ (2013) 24 EJIL 819.
International Convention for the Protection of All Persons from Enforced Disappearance (adopted 20 December 2006) 2716 UNTS 3.
International Convention on the Protection of the Rights of All Migrant Workers and Members of Their Families (18 December 1990) 2220 UNTS 3.
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights 999 UNTS 171 (ICCPR)
King, Hugh "The extraterritorial Human Rights Obligations of States" (2009) 9 Human Rights Law Review 521.
Kleffner, Jann. "Section IX of the ICRC Interpretative Guidance on Direct Participation on hostilities: The end of Jus in Bello proportionality as we know it?" (2012) 45 ILR 35
Lauren, Paul. The evolution of International Human Rights: Visions Seen. UPP, 2011
League of Arab States; African Court of Human and People"™s Rights and Protocol to the African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights on the Rights of Women in Africa (13 September 2000) African Union CAB/LEG/66.6.
Lieber Code (1863).
May, Larry. "Humanity, Necessity and the Rights of soldiers" https://www.law.upenn.edu/live/files/3026-larry-mayhumanity-necessity-and-the-rights-of (accessed: august 2016).
Melzer, Nils."˜Targeted Killing or Less Harmful Means? - Israel's High Court Judgment on Targeted Killing and the Restrictive Function of Military Necessity"™, 9 YIHL 87 (2006).
Meyrowitz, Henri. "Le droit de la guerre et les droit de l"™homme" (1972) 88 Revue du droit public et de la science politique en France et à l"™étranger 1059.
Milanovic, Marco. "Norm Conflicts, International Humanitarian Law, and Human Rights Law" p. 7 in Ben-Naftali, Orna, International Humanitarian Law and International Human Rights Law. Oxford University Press, 2011.
Milanovic, Marco. Extraterritorial Application of HR Treaties: Law, principles and Policy OUP, 2011.
Nüremberg International Military Tribunal, Judgment on the Trial of German Major War Criminals (1946) reprinted in AJIL, Vol. 41, 1947.
Ohlin, Jens David. "˜The Duty to Capture"™, 97 Minnesota Law Review (2013) 1268.
Oppenheim, Lassa. International Law, Vol. II, Disputes, War and Neutrality. Longman"™s, Green & Co. 1952.
Optional Protocol to the Convention Against Torture (adopted 18 December 2002) 2375 UNTS 273.
Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (adopted 13 December 2006) 2518 UNTS 283.
Optional protocol to the Convention on the Rights of the Child on the involvement of children in armed conflict (adopted 25 May 2000) 2173 UNTS 222.
Optional protocol to the Convention on the Rights of the Child on the sale of children, child prostitution and child pornography (adopted 25 May 2000) 2173 UNTS 222.
Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Rights of the Child on a communications procedure (adopted 19 December 2011).
Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (adopted 10 December 2008).
Parks, Hays. "Part IX of the ICRC "˜Direct Participation in Hostilities"™ Study: No Mandate, No Expertise, and Legally Incorrect", (2010) 42 NYU J Int"™l L & Politics 794.
Pease, Kelly Kate and Forsythe, David. Human Rights, Humanitarian Intervention, and World Politics, Human Rights Quarterly, 1993.
Poudyal, Kedar Prasad. The role of national human rights institutions in armed conflict situations, with special reference to NHRC-Nepal. Danish Institute for Human Rights, 2006.
Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949, and relating to the Protection of Victims of Non-International Armed Conflicts 1125 UNTS 609 (APII).
Report of the un Fact-Finding Mission on the Gaza Conflict (25 September 2009) UN Doc A/HCR/12/48.
Rome Statue of the International Criminal Court (adopted 17 July 1998) 2187 UNTS 3.
Rusinova, Vera. "The right to life in light of the integration between the norms of International Humanitarian and Human Rights Law" http://www.hse.ru/data/2014/05/12/1321656524/38LAW2014.pdf (accessed: July 2016).
Sassoli, Marco and Olson, Laura "The relationship between international humanitarian and human rights law where it matters: admissible killing and internment of fighters in non-international armed conflicts" (2008) 90 IRRC 599.
SC Res. 1019 (9 November 1995) UN Doc. S/RES/1019; SC Res. 1635 (28 October 2005) UN Doc. S/RES/1635 and SC Res. 1653 (27 January 2006) UN Doc. S/RES/1653.
SC Res. 237 (14 June 1967) UN Doc. A/237/1967.
St. Petersburg Declaration Renouncing the Use, in Time of War, of Explosive Projectiles Under 400 Grammes Weight LXIV UKPP (1869) 659.
The Manual of the Law of Armed Conflict, UK Ministry of Defence. OUP, 2004.
UN World Summit Outcome Report (24 October 2005) UN Doc. A/RES/60/1.
Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948) UNGA Res 217 A(III), UN Doc A/810 91 (UDHR).
Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties 11 UNTS 331 (VCLT).
Watkin, Kenneth. "Humans in the Cross- Hairs: Targeting, Assassination and Extra-Legal Killing in Contemporary Armed Conflict", in Wippman, David and Evangelista, Matthew. New Wars, New Laws? applying the laws of war in the 21st century conflicts. Brill, 2005.
Westlake, John. International Law, Part II, War. CUP, 1907.
Wicks, Elizabeth. The Right to Life and Conflicting Interests. Oxford Scholarship, 2010. www2.ohchr.org/english/bodies/hrc/docs/CCPR.C.ISR.CO.3.doc (accessed: august 2016).
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
In relation to copy rights, authors publishing with USFQ Law Review know and accept its internal policies, including but not limited to:
1. Open Access Policy.
2. Authorship Policy.
3. Copyright Policy.
4. Pre-Publication Policy.
5. Post-Publication Policy.
6. Intellectual Property Protection Policy.
7. Digital Preservation Policy.
