IURIS DICTIO - EVALUATION SHEET

In this section the user can find the evaluation sheet the reviewers have to answer when they have an assigned article.

 

ARTICLE"™S TITLE:

On a scale from 1 to 5, with 5 being excellent and 1 very poor, please evaluate the following aspects:

1. PRECISE TITLE AND ACCURATE ABSTRACT

1. Very poor
2. Poor
3. Intermediate
4. Good
5. Excellent

Comments:

 

 

2. APPROACH TO THE PROBLEM

1. Very poor
2. Poor
3. Intermediate
4. Good
5. Excellent

Comments:

 

3. ARTICLE"™S ORGANIZATION

1. Very poor
2. Poor
3. Intermediate
4. Good
5. Excellent

Comments:

 

4. TOPIC"™S RELEVANCE AND RECENT BIBLIOGRAPHY

1. Very poor
2. Poor
3. Intermediate
4. Good
5. Excellent

Comments:

 

5. ORIGINALITY AND CONTRIBUTION TO ITS AREA OF SPECIALIZATION

1. Very poor
2. Poor
3. Intermediate
4. Good
5. Excellent

Comments:

 

6. ORGANIZATION, COMPOSITION, AND STYLE

1. Very poor
2. Poor
3. Intermediate
4. Good
5. Excellent

Comments:

 

7. MANDATORY CHANGES IN ORDER TO PUBLISH

 

 

8. GENERAL COMMENTS

 

 

9. FINAL DECISION

To publish
Not to publish
To publish with changes